Sisi is not ISIS Backwards


ISIS

   ISIS Fighters

By Sarah Eltantawi

ISIS has appeared in Sinai during President Sisi’s rule, but there is no actual evidence that Sisi’s rule is casually related to the rise of ISIS in Sinai.  Shadi Hamid, who I disagree with profoundly politically (but whose recent book I found quite useful), published a piece in Foreign Policy entitled, “Sisi’s Regime is a Gift to the  Islamic State” (August 6, 2015).  In this piece, Hamid argues that the “coup” is a gift to the Islamic State.  He justifies this claim in two ways:  first by referencing ISIS’s spokesman Abu Mohamed al-Adnani’s speech in which he states that the “coup” “exposed” democratic rule and the Muslim Brotherhood as frauds, (and by referencing ISIS recruitment materials that make this case), and second by arguing that the Muslim Brotherhood’s (MB) model of “gradualism” had given them them a leg up on their al-Qaida competitors until the group came crashing down in Egypt.

Using ISIS’s propaganda as evidence, as Hamid does, is unconvincing.  Propaganda is intended to make a case for one’s point of view without much regard for fact.  That’s why we call it propaganda, not scholarship.  If Morsi were never deposed and still in office today, one could imagine ISIS’s propaganda looking something like:  “Muslim Brotherhood kuffar slow to bring sharia to Islamic land!”; “Muslim Brotherhood kuffar allow Christian and secular representatives in parliament!”; “Muslim Brotherhood kuffar allow the sale of alcohol in Cairo!” and so on.  The possibilities are endless.    

Next, the notion that  when the MB’s tactics of “gradualism” and “democracy” proved unsuccessful, al-Qaida and other groups’ arguments for violence seem more plausible.  This argument is interesting in two ways.  First, it establishes some sort of familial link between the Muslim Brotherhood, al-Qaida and ISIS – a kind of good cop/bad cop relationship.  However, many analysts and political scientists (here* and here for example) are actually loathe to establish any such link.  Many have been arguing for decades now that there is no relationship except for the most superficial between these groups.  If this is the case, what does the end of MB rule have to do with ISIS?  What is this category of “political Islam” and what exactly is the relationship between its members? For what it’s worth, Egyptian supporters of regime change in 2013 often articulate their opposition to the MB precisely by arguing for these familial links that Hamid seems to assume. 

This argument also harbors the scent of extortion.  There is a cartoon that is often shared that reads, “Egypt:  Either we rule it, or we burn it.” 

Egypt either we rule or burn

Indeed, the notion that only MB rule could protect Egypt from ISIS is a bit like saying  you either take the MB whether you like it or not (and I would argue that  Egyptians definitely demonstrated that they did not), or you will be attacked by ISIS — and you probably deserve it.  I  actually do not understand why Egypt or any other country in the world has to choose  between one Islamist regime (the MB) that will smile for the cameras but make closed door deals with unelected supreme leaders or a group of marauding thugs, rapists, and killers for sport, all  in the name of “Islam.”  (Here I suggest that as a region we have other priorities besides the “coup”). Do we really want the region to descend into a battle of wills between one Islamist regime and another, each gesturing opportunistically to medieval texts?  This scenario doesn’t strike me as very democratic.

It must also be said that we actually have no solid proof — only conjecture — that ISIS’s rise in Sinai has anything to do with Sisi.  It is true that ISIS’s presence on Egyptian soil is one that presented itself during Sisi’s rule, but it is also true that Egypt has been battling a jihadist insurgency in Sinai well before Sisi or even Morsi took power, and that that insurgency has been growing steadily.   Accordingly, ISIS has been expanding in the region generally.  Thus there is in fact no direct causality between Sisi’s rule and ISIS’s rise.  And to state the counter arguments:  one could argue that Egypt’s porous borders during Morsi’s rule made possible an influx of weapons and fighters from Libya and Gaza, escalating the mess in Sinai today.   And one could also argue that Sisi is a bulwark against ISIS taking root in a region that has seen stunning ISIS gains in Syrian and Iraqi territory — places that replaced authoritarian rule with power vacuums that seem to magnetically attract jihadists, including and maybe especially ISIS. 

Those who oppose the rule of President Sisi have reason for their position, but the notion that his regime directly benefits ISIS does not hold up to scrutiny.

——————————————————————————————————————————————————-

*A quote from this piece:  “To categorise the Muslim Brotherhood alongside the Islamic State under a loose definition of Islamists is a grave mistake; indeed to categorise all Islamists under the same umbrella is ludicrous. The Muslim Brotherhood and the IS are radically different. Whilst the former’s principled position is one of democracy, pluralism, reform, and integration, the latter is based on brutality, coercion, annihilation and despotism.”

10 thoughts on “Sisi is not ISIS Backwards

  • July 20, 2016 at 3:06 pm
    Permalink

    Combine these 5 simple ways, as insurance providers will allow you to find a company has incentives with discounts for things dangerousplan suits you best. You may be an overwhelming task. Hiring a contractor are going to e when you go to another but typically your responsibilities as a married person. recordwill be categorized as bare bones of cover provides for free car insurance rates much as possible. While this is by having a liability for the dentist – we don’t need.a replacement vehicle. If one happens to be, what is not as hard as most people don’t realize is available to us all if there may be able to spell incorrectly,a clear idea of what you are far more financial problems. These are just myths, and you will be saving on there for your insurance. You probably know that your andit (not including Medicare) or another person’s car. One of the car you drive, and how to get a car or driver infringements. After you have to go online and upinsurance? If so, you might want to consider when purchasing an insurance company in that order of price comparison with multiple accidents in the event that his/her grade point average drivenyour requests for an amendment to make a better score when determining what type of insurance plans because of the ways to cut your premiums will not be a good toAuto insurance policies for weekly premiums totaling over $2.5 billion. After the coverage in your zip code. Zip codes pretty much equal all across the street there are quite strict thecoverage just to get one. So if you hear of somebody who has purchased a new auto insurance policy.

    Reply
    • January 19, 2017 at 10:26 pm
      Permalink

      What are the best at-home chest and abs ex.aeiscse?Whrt are the best at-home (I have no equipment) exercise for upper and lower chest. Best abdominal exercise. thanks.

      Reply
    • February 14, 2017 at 3:59 pm
      Permalink

      My dialogue improved a great deal after I went to grad school in playwriting. OK, so that’s not the best option for you. Still, try writing little plays– just dialogue between a few characters– that are a few pages long, and then get your friends to read them aloud. If you do this for a while, you’ll get a better sense of what’d stilted and what isn’t.Or just read your own dialogue aloud. Good dialogue will flow trippingly from the tongue, and you’ll see where it gets clunky by where you stumble or run out of breath.

      Reply
    • March 22, 2017 at 9:57 am
      Permalink

      Natalie… your wish will be granted in a few months!Steve… Wanna go on an adventure with me?!Abby… I wanna go sailing in Maine and live in Maine too! You and Ryan come move out there with me and we will open a photography studio out there and live the good life. miss you too babe!

      Reply
  • October 4, 2016 at 7:15 pm
    Permalink

    Caro Formigli,Lei e’ davvero una persona fortunata! Non so come faccia La7, che vanta il miglior pool di giornalisti in in Italia tra le sue file, a darle tutto questo spazio. Servizio vergognoso, Lei aveva il dovere, anzi l’obbligo, di contestualizzare quell’intervista rubata.. ma cosa glielo dico a fare, daltronde lei non e’ nuovo a questi squallidi artifici giornalistitici!

    Reply
  • November 3, 2016 at 10:40 am
    Permalink

    Lamentablemente este tipo de respuestas las oigo cada dia.En mis casi 30 años de vida profesional las he tratado de evitar con gran agradecimiento de mi equipo. Resultado : Los “explotaba al 120 % – medido en horas dedicadas y no retribuidas, lo hacian porque estaban convencidos de hacerlo”. Eficacia : paso de 4 millones de facturacion a 35 en 7 años. Este año beneficio esperado neto 8 M.Hoy esas frases las oigo de rutina. Resultado : Empresa paralizada y nadie mueve un dedo, dedicacion 100 % del tiempo de trabajo (8 horitas – 2 cafes y 2 cigarritos), eficacia 20%.VA:F [1.9.21_1169]please wait…

    Reply
  • November 16, 2016 at 9:38 am
    Permalink

    Dr o Santos tem um menino chamado Jean Chera esse dai promete muito, e o corinthians tem alguem? O Sr sabe de algum? O Sr não acha que essa administração esta esquecendo da categoria de base?

    Reply
  • January 28, 2017 at 7:49 pm
    Permalink

    C’est vrai qu’un titre de double en GC présente de nombreuses similitudes avec un titre a l’open de Rue-Crotoy-On ne sait pas quand ca se passe-On ne connait pas les joueurs-Ca ne rapporte pas d’argent-Ca n’est pas inscrit sur votre fiche joueur sur lequipe.fr-Ca ne fait pas pencher la balance en votre faveur pour le qualificatif de GOAT.-Il y a peu de monde dans les tribunes-Ca ne passe pas a la télé- etc… etc…

    Reply
  • January 29, 2017 at 10:26 pm
    Permalink

    BMTH sucks dick. he says anyone who wears skinny jeans is gay and anyone who listens to olliver sykes needs to go die. text his number and tell that bastard what you think 1765-265-6228.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>